The Illusion of Simplicity

​

"Aspiration pneumonia." The diagnosis seems straightforward, a simple equation: if aspiration… then pneumonia. But is it really that simple? Early in my career, an aspiration pneumonia (AP) diagnosis felt like a personal failure, a stark testament to my perceived inadequacy. I was the security guard for the lungs, and I somehow fell asleep long enough to allow a bunch of microscopic critters to have a party in the lungs all night long. I've since learned that this label, AP, is often applied with a broad brush like a 3-year-old painting with their hands. This wide application hides a complex and nuanced reality. Let me paint the picture as it's supposed to be painted.

​

​

Dissecting the Definitions: Aspiration and Pneumonia

Let's dissect the term. Aspiration, inhaling foreign material into the lungs, raises critical questions. Where did this material originate? Was it a top-down event involving food or liquid swallowed from the mouth ((i.e., anterograde aspiration) or a bottom-up occurrence involving refluxed secretions (i.e., retrograde aspiration)? And what was it? Secretions, or a specific type of food or liquid? 

​

Pneumonia, an infection of the lungs, similarly demands deeper inquiry. Was it viral, bacterial, or fungal? Which lung segments were involved? And crucially, did the pneumonia precede or follow the onset of dysphagia? The "chicken or the egg" conundrum, as so eloquently described by Dr. James Coyle.

​

The Danger of Oversimplification

The truth is that branding the AP label on a patient may oversimplify a multifaceted clinical picture. The fact of the matter is that we ALL aspirate. Yes, even you. It occurs during meals as a bit of trace aspiration makes us unconsciously cough or clear our throat. Further, we can experience micro-aspirations during sleep and not even know it. Yet, most of us remain strong and healthy without concerns about AP. Focusing solely on swallowing while neglecting other pneumonia risk factors is like judging a three-hour film based on its 30-second trailer. We miss the intricate plot, the underlying themes, and the complex character interactions. In AP, we miss the most important factors, which prevents us from recognizing the problem, managing it effectively, and possibly preventing it from occurring.

​

 

The Importance of Dysphagia, Within Context

Of course, the previous section is not meant to diminish the importance of dysphagia assessment and management. Dysphagia significantly impacts quality of life, and aspiration can cause serious pulmonary infections and respiratory issues. However, we must move beyond a narrow focus. Instead, we should adopt a holistic approach, asking two critical questions: what is being aspirated, and who is aspirating it? The first requires detailed instrumental assessments, such as MBSS or FEES, to determine the nature and volume of aspirate. The second necessitates evaluating the patient's ability to clear the aspirate and mount an effective immune response. 

​

A young, healthy individual with trace aspiration on thin liquids presents a vastly different risk profile than an elderly patient with cardiopulmonary comorbidities and gross aspiration on all consistencies. Treating these two patients the same would be like treating a paper cut and a lacerated artery with the same time, resources, and surgical procedures. That wouldn't make sense, right? There's a better way.

 

Quantifying Risk: A Patient-Centered Approach

Our goal should be to measure the risk of pneumonia, however crude that measure, before implementing dysphagia management strategies to lower that risk. Understanding the level of risk and discussing it with the patient first helps us determine if drastic approaches should be implemented (e.g., modified diets, NPO status, and feeding tubes). If not, can we incorporate other interventions while promoting a less restrictive diet and quality of life (e.g., oral hygiene protocols, increasing mobility, promoting self-care, incorporating dysphagia exercises, etc.)?

 

Beyond the Trailer: Understanding the Full Story

Ultimately, we must move beyond the trailer and delve into the full story. By understanding the interplay between aspiration, patient-specific risk factors, and the multifaceted nature of pneumonia, we can provide patient-centered care and move past the oversimplified label of "aspiration pneumonia." If you want to learn more about the different types of pneumonia, assessing risk, and assigning interventions, check out my course on the topic. 
 

​

If you liked this article, please sign up for George's blog by emailing him at George@The-DysphagiaExpert.com or scrolling to the bottom of my website. George frequently posts new dysphagia articles!